Skip Navigation

		COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES PHILOSOPHY HOME PAGE COLLOQUIUM CALENDAR
FACULTY GRADUATE STUDENTS COLLOQUIUM CALENDAR UNDERGRADUATE PROGRAM GRADUATE PROGRAM GRADUATE PLACEMENT CONTACT US MASTER SCHEDULE UNDERGRADUATE BULLETIN GRADUATE BULLETIN ACADEMIC CALENDARS USC LIBRARIES CAS COMPUTING & IT USC COMPUTER SERVICES ABOUT COLUMBIA SC RESTRICTED ACCESS: Faculty | Graduate Students Search USC   THIS SITE		COLLOQUIA & CONFERENCES DREAMING   Jody Azzouni Department of Philosophy Tufts University   September 25, 2003 Thursday, 4:00pm-6:00pm Nursing, Room 125   Two versions of "the" dreaming argument are distinguished. A strong version of the argument, which uses very weak premises, in particular, which does not require assumptions about the epistemic relevance of "possibilities," is here examined. It is shown how considerations involving both impaired judgment and lucid dreaming are entangled in ways that give the argument plausibility. An "intoxication" argument (how do I know that I'm not drunk right now?) is used to show that psychological states that induce poor judgment are not themselves (alone) powerful enough to motivate skepticism; and plausible symmetry conditions on confusion (that if A can be confused with B, then B should be confusable with A as well), show that "lucid dream" considerations, if powerful enough to motivate skepticism, are not compatible with what actual dreams are like.
RETURN TO TOP		USC LINKS: DIRECTORY MAP EVENTS VIP	SITE INFORMATION
Last updated 5/24/08 4:22 PM • burke@sc.edu   © 2006 University of South Carolina Board of Trustees