|
|
COLLOQUIA & CONFERENCES
DESCARTES ON THE LIMITS OF REASON
Matthew Kisner
Department of Philosophy
University of South Carolina
October 21, 2005
Friday, 4:00pm-6:00pm
Nursing, Room 127
It is common to regard Descartes as exceedingly optimistic about the powers
of reason. This interpretive line culminates in the claim that Descartes
conceives of reason as a kind of divine power, occupying a God's-eye
perspective. This paper examines Descartes' view on the limits of reason. I
show that Descartes conceives of human reason, in opposition to divine
reason, as a part of the natural world, dependent upon, and thus limited by
other things, namely bodies and the will. I address an urgent epistemic
question which arises from this view: if we cannot know the world as God
knows it, then how can we claim to possess absolutely certain knowledge?
An answer to this question can be found in a controversial passage from the
Second Replies. There Descartes argues that knowledge only requires
justification from the perspective of human reason, thereby rejecting the
God's-eye perspective.
 |
|