Standard Country Code
Name of Case (SCRA top of page)
Case Identification Number
Initials for Reporter in Which Case Found
Volume
Beginning Page
Ending Page
Decision Date
Year of Decision
Month of Decision
Day of Decision
Oral Argument Beginning Date
Oral Argument Ending Date
Multiple Cases Decided (not coded)
Court or Agency of Initial Origin - original code
Province of Origin Court or Agency
Origin Court or Agency
Court or Agency of Original Origin - original code
Province of Source Court or Agency
Source Court or Agency
No. of Formal NonParty participants (Amicus intervenors)
Number of Appelant Natural Persons
Number of Appellant Businesses
Number of Appellant NGOs and Associations
Number of Appellant SuNational Government Liitgants
Number of Appellant National Government Litigants
Number of Appellant Fiduciaries
Number of Respondent Natural Persons
Number of Respondent Businesses
Number of Respondent NGOs and Associations
Number of Respondent SubNational Government Litigants
Number of Respondent National Government Litigants
Number of Respondent Fiduciaries
Type of  Petitioner/Appellant 1
Province of Appellant 1 if corporate
Appelant 1 - New codes (Code As Listed In Title)
Appellant 1 Category Type
Type of  Petitioner/Appellant 2
Province of Appellant 2 if corporate
Appelant 2 - New codes (Code As Listed In Title)
Appellant 2 Category Type
Type of  Appellee/Respondent 1
Province of Respondent 1 if corporate
Respondent 1 - New codes (Code As Listed In Title)
Respondent 1 Category Type
Type of  Appellee/Respondent 2
Province of Respondent 2 if corporate
Respondent 2- New codes (Code As Listed In Title)
Respondent 2 Category Type
Plaintiff = Appelant, Respondent or Other
Treatment of Decision of Source
Who Wins in Supreme Court
Number of Votes in the Majority
Number of Votes in Dissent (Includes Partial Dissents)
First Substantive Issue
Directionality - 1st Substantive Issue
Second Substantive Issue
Directionality - 2nd Substantive Issue
Constitutional Issue Discussed?
Level of Constitutional Review
Outcome of Constitutional Review
Basis of Constitutional Review
Threshold Issue Discussed?
Jury Issue Discussed?
Sufficiency of Evidence Issue Discussed?
Confession Admissibility Issue Discussed?
Evidence Admissibility Issue Discussed?
Police Misconduct Issue Discussed?
Prosection Misconduct Issue Discussed?
Death Penalty Issue Discussed?
Challenge to Punishment Issue Discussed?
Statutory Interpretation Issue Discussed?
Abuse of Authority Issue Discussed?
Adequacy of Counsel Issue Discussed?
Procedural Fairness Issue Discussed?
Opinion not in English
How Were Costs Assessed?
Name Appellant attorney 1
Name Appellant attorney 2
Name Appellant attorney 3
Name Appellant attorney 4
Name Appellant attorney 5
Name Respondent attorney 1
Name Respondent attorney 3
Name Respondent attorney 4
Name Respondent attorney 5
Reference Case?
Vote 1 J #062 Concepcion, Roberto R. (RRC) 09/02/1954   (as CJ) 17/06/1966-18/04
Vote 1 J #064 Reyes, J. B. L. (JBR) 30/06/1954-19/08/1972
Vote 1 J #069 Dizon, Arsenio P. (APD) 26/07/1960-05/10/1971
Vote 1 J #074 Makalintal, Querebe (QCM) 23/05/1962   (as CJ)21/10/1973-22/12/197
Vote 1 J #075 Zaldivar, Calixto (COZ) 12/09/1964-13/09/1974
Vote 1 J #077 Sanchez, Conrado V. (CVS) 29/05/1966-19/02/1970
Vote 1 J #078 Castro, Fred Ruiz (FRC) 29/05/1966   (as CJ) 05/01/1976-19/04/1979
Vote 1 J #080 Fernando, Enrique M. (EMF) 30/06/1967   (as CJ) 02/07/1979-24/07/1
Vote 1 or j #081 Capistrano, Francisco R. (FC) 16/09/1968-06/10/1969
Vote 1 J #082 Teehankee, Claudio (CT) 17/12/1968   (as CJ) 02/04/1986-18/04/1988
Vote 1 J #083 Barredo, Antonio P. (APB) 17/12/1968-01/10/1982
Vote 1 J #084 Villamor, Julio V. (JVV) 24/01/1970-12/04/1972
Vote 1 J #085 Makasiar, Felix V. (FVM) 02/08/1970   (as CJ) 25/07/1985-19/11/198
Vote 1 J #086 Antonio, Felix Q. (FQA) ??/06/1972-18/05/1980
Vote 1 J #087 Esguerra, Salvador V. (SVE) ??/06/1972-19/06/1976
Vote 1 J #088 Fernandez, Estanislao A. (EAF) 29/10/1973-28/03/1975
Vote 1 J #089 Munoz Palma, Cecelia (CMP) 29/10/1973-22/11/1978
Vote 1 J #090 Aquino, Ramon C. (RCA) 29/10/1973   (as CJ) 20/11/1985-06/03/1986
Vote 1 J #091 Concepcion, Jr., Hermogenes (HC) 18/04/1975-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #092 Martin, Ruperto G. (RGM) 18/04/1975-10/01/1978
Vote 1 J #093 Santos, Guillermo S. (GSS) 27/05/1977-23/01/1980
Vote 1 J #094 Fernandez, Ramon C. (RCF) 27/05/1977-11/05/1982
Vote 1 J #095 Guerrero, Juvenal K. (JKG) 27/05/1977-04/11/1984
Vote 1 J #096 Abad Santos, Vicente (VAS) 17/01/1979-03/04/1986
Vote 1 J #097 Decastro, Pacifico P. (PPD) 17/01/1979-31/05/1984
Vote 1 J #098 Melencio Herrera, Ameurfina (AMH) 17/01/1979-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #099 Ericta, Vicente G. (VGE) 20/11/1981-11/05/1982
Vote 1 J #100 Plana, Efren I. (EIP) 20/11/1981-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #101 Escolin, Venicio T. (VTE) 20/11/1981-15/04/1986
Vote 1 J #102 Vasquez, Conrado M. (CMV) 14/05/1982-30/09/1983
Vote 1 J #103 Relova, Lorenzo (LR) 14/05/1982-19/01/1986
Vote 1 J #104 Gutierrez, Jr., Hugo E. (HEG) 14/05/1982-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #105 de la Fuente, Buenaventura (BDF) 28/02/1984-06/03/1986
Vote 1 J #106 Cuevas, Serafin R. (SRC) 01/06/1984-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #107 Alampay, Nestor B. (NBA) 24/01/1985-17/03/1987
Vote 1 J #108 Patajo, Lino M. (LMP) 31/07/1985-16/04/1986
Vote 1 J #109 Feria, Jose Y. (JYF) 07/04/1986-11/01/1987
Vote 1 J #110 Yap, Pedro L. (PLY) 08/04/1986 (as CJ??) 18-04-1988-01/07/1988??
Vote 1 J #111 Fernan, Marcelo N. (MNF) 09/04/1986 (as CJ??)-08/12/1991
Vote 1 J #112 Narvasa, Andres R. (ARN) 10/04/1986 (as CJ??)-30/11/1998
Vote 1 J #113 Cruz, Isagani A. (IAC) 16/04/1986-11/10/1994
Vote 1 J #114 Paras, Edgardo L. (ELP) 16/04/1986-04/07/1992
Vote 1 J #115 Feliciano, Florentino P. (FPF) 08/08/1986-13/12/1995
Vote 1 J #116 Gancayco, Emilio A. (EAG) 12/01/1987-20/07/1991
Vote 1 J #117 Padilla, Teodoro R. (TRP) 12/01/1987-24/08/1997
Vote 1 J #118 Bidin, Abdulwahid A. (AAB) 12/01/1987-07/04/1995
Vote 1 J #119 Sarmiento, Abraham F. (AFS) 26/01/1987-08/10/1991
Vote 1 J #120 Cortes, Irene R. (IRC) 01/02/1987-20/10/1991
Vote 1 J #121 Griño-Aquino, Carolina (CGA) 02/02/1988-24/10/1993
Vote 1 J #122 Medialidea, Leo D. (LDM) 26/04/1988-06/11/1992
Vote 1 J #123 Regalado, Florenz D. (FDR) 29/07/1988-13/11/1998
Vote 1 J #124 Davide, Jr., Hilario G. (HGD) 28/01/1991 (as CJ 30/11/1998)
Vote 1 J #125 Romero, Florida Ruth P. (FPR) 09/10/1991-31/07/1999
Vote 1 J #126 Nocon, Rodolfo A. (RAN) 28/11/1991-15/03/1994
Vote 1 J #127 Bellosillo, Josue N. (JNB) 03/03/1992-13/11/2003?
Vote 1 J #128 Melo, Jose A.R. (JAM) 27/07/1992???-28/05/1992
Vote 1 J #129 Campos, Jr., Jose C. (JCC) 04/09/1992-09/04/2003
Vote 1 J #130 Quiason, Camilo D. (CDQ) 01/02/1993-18/07/1995
Vote 1 J #131 Puno, Reynato S. (RSP) 28/06/1993-
Vote 1 J #132 Vitug, Jose C. (JCV) 28/06/1993-07/14/2004
Vote 1 J #133 Kapunan, Santiago M. (SMK) 05/01/1994-12/08/2002?
Vote 1 J #134 Mendoza, Vicente V. (VVM) 25/05/1994-05/04/2003?
Vote 1 J #135 Francisco, Ricardo J. (RJF) 17/01/1995-13/02/1998
Vote 1 J #136 Hermosisima, Jr., Regino C. (RCH) 18/07/1995-18/10/1997
Vote 1 J #137 Panganiban, Artemio V. (AVP) 10/10/1995-
Vote 1 J #138 Justo P. Torres, Jr. (JPT) 23/03/1996-01/11/1997
Vote 1 J #139 Antonio M. Martinez (AMM)17/11/1997-01/02/1999
Vote 1 J #140 Quisumbing, Leonardo A. (LAQ) 15/01/1998 -
Vote 1 J #141 Fidel P. Purisima (FPP) 27/01/1998-???
Vote 1 J #142 Pardo, Bernardo P. (BPP) 06/11/1998-11/2/2002?
Vote 1 J #143 Buena, Arturo B. (ABB) 05/01/1999-25/03/2002?
Vote 1 J #144 Gonzaga-Reyes, Minerva P. (MPG) 05/01/1999-25/09/2001?
Vote 1 J #145 Ynares-Santiago, Ma. Consuelo (MCY)-06/04/1999-
Vote 1 J #146 De Leon, Jr., Sabino R. (SRD) ??/10/1999-09/06/2002? or 28/05/2002
Vote 1 J #147? Sandoval-Gutierrez, Angelina (ASG) 22/12/2000-
Vote 1 J #148? Carpio, Antonio T. (ATC) 26/10/2001-
Vote 1 J #149? Austria-Martinez, Ma. Alicia (MAA) 12/04/2002-
Vote 1 J #150? Corona, Renato C. (RCC) 12/04/2002-
Vote 1 J #151? Carpio-Morales, Conchita (CCM) 03/09/2002-
Vote 1 J #152? Callejo, Sr., Romeo J. (RJC) 03/09/2002-
Vote 1 J #153? Azcuna, Adolfo S. (ASA) 17/10/2002-
Vote 1 J #154? Tinga, Dante O. (DOT) 04/07/2003-
Vote 1 J #155? Chico-Nazario, Minita (MCN) 14/07/2004-
Vote 1 J #156? Garcia, Cancio C. (CCG) 06/10/2004-
Vote 2 J #080 Fernando, Enrique M. (EMF) 30/06/1967   (as CJ) 02/07/1979-24/07/1
Vote 2 J #082 Teehankee, Claudio (CT) 17/12/1968   (as CJ) 02/04/1986-18/04/1988
Vote 2 J #085 Makasiar, Felix V. (FVM) 02/08/1970   (as CJ) 25/07/1985-19/11/198
Vote 2 J #090 Aquino, Ramon C. (RCA) 29/10/1973   (as CJ) 20/11/1985-06/03/1986
Vote 2 J #091 Concepcion, Jr., Hermogenes (HC) 18/04/1975-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #095 Guerrero, Juvenal K. (JKG) 27/05/1977-04/11/1984
Vote 2 J #096 Abad Santos, Vicente (VAS) 17/01/1979-03/04/1986
Vote 2 J #097 Decastro, Pacifico P. (PPD) 17/01/1979-31/05/1984
Vote 2 J #098 Melencio Herrera, Ameurfina (AMH) 17/01/1979-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #100 Plana, Efren I. (EIP) 20/11/1981-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #101 Escolin, Venicio T. (VTE) 20/11/1981-15/04/1986
Vote 2 J #103 Relova, Lorenzo (LR) 14/05/1982-19/01/1986
Vote 2 J #104 Gutierrez, Jr., Hugo E. (HEG) 14/05/1982-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #105 de la Fuente, Buenaventura (BDF) 28/02/1984-06/03/1986
Vote 2 J #106 Cuevas, Serafin R. (SRC) 01/06/1984-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #107 Alampay, Nestor B. (NBA) 24/01/1985-17/03/1987
Vote 2 J #108 Patajo, Lino M. (LMP) 31/07/1985-16/04/1986
Vote 2 J #109 Feria, Jose Y. (JYF) 07/04/1986-11/01/1987
Vote 2 J #110 Yap, Pedro L. (PLY) 08/04/1986 (as CJ??) 18-04-1988-01/07/1988??
Vote 2 J #111 Fernan, Marcelo N. (MNF) 09/04/1986 (as CJ??)-08/12/1991
Vote 2 J #112 Narvasa, Andres R. (ARN) 10/04/1986 (as CJ??)-30/11/1998
Vote 2 J #113 Cruz, Isagani A. (IAC) 16/04/1986-11/10/1994
Vote 2 J #114 Paras, Edgardo L. (ELP) 16/04/1986-04/07/1992
Vote 2 J #115 Feliciano, Florentino P. (FPF) 08/08/1986-13/12/1995
Vote 2 J #116 Gancayco, Emilio A. (EAG) 12/01/1987-20/07/1991
Vote 2 J #117 Padilla, Teodoro R. (TRP) 12/01/1987-24/08/1997
Vote 2 J #118 Bidin, Abdulwahid A. (AAB) 12/01/1987-07/04/1995
Vote 2 J #119 Sarmiento, Abraham F. (AFS) 26/01/1987-08/10/1991
Vote 2 J #120 Cortes, Irene R. (IRC) 01/02/1987-20/10/1991
Vote 2 J #121 Griño-Aquino, Carolina (CGA) 02/02/1988-24/10/1993
Vote 2 J #122 Medialidea, Leo D. (LDM) 26/04/1988-06/11/1992
Vote 2 J #123 Regalado, Florenz D. (FDR) 29/07/1988-13/11/1998
Vote 2 J #124 Davide, Jr., Hilario G. (HGD) 28/01/1991 (as CJ 30/11/1998)
Vote 2 J #125 Romero, Florida Ruth P. (FPR) 09/10/1991-31/07/1999
Vote 2 J #126 Nocon, Rodolfo A. (RAN) 28/11/1991-15/03/1994
Vote 2 J #127 Bellosillo, Josue N. (JNB) 03/03/1992-13/11/2003?
Vote 2 J #128 Melo, Jose A.R. (JAM) 27/07/1992???-28/05/1992
Vote 2 J #129 Campos, Jr., Jose C. (JCC) 04/09/1992-09/04/2003
Vote 2 J #130 Quiason, Camilo D. (CDQ) 01/02/1993-18/07/1995
Vote 2 J #131 Puno, Reynato S. (RSP) 28/06/1993-
Vote 2 J #132 Vitug, Jose C. (JCV) 28/06/1993-07/14/2004
Vote 2 J #133 Kapunan, Santiago M. (SMK) 05/01/1994-12/08/2002?
Vote 2 J #134 Mendoza, Vicente V. (VVM) 25/05/1994-05/04/2003?
Vote 2 J #135 Francisco, Ricardo J. (RJF) 17/01/1995-13/02/1998
Vote 2 J #136 Hermosisima, Jr., Regino C. (RCH) 18/07/1995-18/10/1997
Vote 2 J #137 Panganiban, Artemio V. (AVP) 10/10/1995-
Vote 2 J #138 Justo P. Torres, Jr. (JPT) 23/03/1996-01/11/1997
Vote 2 J #139 Antonio M. Martinez (AMM)17/11/1997-01/02/1999
Vote 2 J #140 Quisumbing, Leonardo A. (LAQ) 15/01/1998 -
Vote 2 J #141 Fidel P. Purisima (FPP) 27/01/1998-???
Vote 2 J #142 Pardo, Bernardo P. (BPP) 06/11/1998-11/2/2002?
Vote 2 J #143 Buena, Arturo B. (ABB) 05/01/1999-25/03/2002?
Vote 2 J #144 Gonzaga-Reyes, Minerva P. (MPG) 05/01/1999-25/09/2001?
Vote 2 J #145 Ynares-Santiago, Ma. Consuelo (MCY)-06/04/1999-
Vote 2 J #146 De Leon, Jr., Sabino R. (SRD) ??/10/1999-09/06/2002? or 28/05/2002
Opinion Behavior J #082 Teehankee, Claudio (CT) 17/12/1968   (as CJ) 02/04/1986-
Opinion Behavior J #085 Makasiar, Felix V. (FVM) 02/08/1970   (as CJ) 25/07/1985
Opinion Behavior J #090 Aquino, Ramon C. (RCA) 29/10/1973   (as CJ) 20/11/1985-0
Opinion Behavior J #091 Concepcion, Jr., Hermogenes (HC) 18/04/1975-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #096 Abad Santos, Vicente (VAS) 17/01/1979-03/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #098 Melencio Herrera, Ameurfina (AMH) 17/01/1979-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #100 Plana, Efren I. (EIP) 20/11/1981-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #101 Escolin, Venicio T. (VTE) 20/11/1981-15/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #103 Relova, Lorenzo (LR) 14/05/1982-19/01/1986
Opinion Behavior J #104 Gutierrez, Jr., Hugo E. (HEG) 14/05/1982-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #105 de la Fuente, Buenaventura (BDF) 28/02/1984-06/03/1986
Opinion Behavior J #106 Cuevas, Serafin R. (SRC) 01/06/1984-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #107 Alampay, Nestor B. (NBA) 24/01/1985-17/03/1987
Opinion Behavior J #108 Patajo, Lino M. (LMP) 31/07/1985-16/04/1986
Opinion Behavior J #109 Feria, Jose Y. (JYF) 07/04/1986-11/01/1987
Opinion Behavior J #110 Yap, Pedro L. (PLY) 08/04/1986 (as CJ??) 18-04-1988-01/0
Opinion Behavior J #111 Fernan, Marcelo N. (MNF) 09/04/1986 (as CJ??)-08/12/1991
Opinion Behavior J #112 Narvasa, Andres R. (ARN) 10/04/1986 (as CJ??)-30/11/1998
Opinion Behavior J #113 Cruz, Isagani A. (IAC) 16/04/1986-11/10/1994
Opinion Behavior J #114 Paras, Edgardo L. (ELP) 16/04/1986-04/07/1992
Opinion Behavior J #115 Feliciano, Florentino P. (FPF) 08/08/1986-13/12/1995
Opinion Behavior J #117 Padilla, Teodoro R. (TRP) 12/01/1987-24/08/1997
Opinion Behavior J #118 Bidin, Abdulwahid A. (AAB) 12/01/1987-07/04/1995
Opinion Behavior J #119 Sarmiento, Abraham F. (AFS) 26/01/1987-08/10/1991
Opinion Behavior J #120 Cortes, Irene R. (IRC) 01/02/1987-20/10/1991
Opinion Behavior J #121 Griño-Aquino, Carolina (CGA) 02/02/1988-24/10/1993
Opinion Behavior J #122 Medialidea, Leo D. (LDM) 26/04/1988-06/11/1992
Opinion Behavior J #123 Regalado, Florenz D. (FDR) 29/07/1988-13/11/1998
Opinion Behavior J #124 Davide, Jr., Hilario G. (HGD) 28/01/1991 (as CJ 30/11/19
Opinion Behavior J #125 Romero, Florida Ruth P. (FPR) 09/10/1991-31/07/1999
Opinion Behavior J #126 Nocon, Rodolfo A. (RAN) 28/11/1991-15/03/1994
Opinion Behavior J #127 Bellosillo, Josue N. (JNB) 03/03/1992-13/11/2003?
Opinion Behavior J #128 Melo, Jose A.R. (JAM) 27/07/1992???-28/05/1992
Opinion Behavior J #129 Campos, Jr., Jose C. (JCC) 04/09/1992-09/04/2003
Opinion Behavior J #130 Quiason, Camilo D. (CDQ) 01/02/1993-18/07/1995
Opinion Behavior J #131 Puno, Reynato S. (RSP) 28/06/1993-
Opinion Behavior J #132 Vitug, Jose C. (JCV) 28/06/1993-07/14/2004
Opinion Behavior J #133 Kapunan, Santiago M. (SMK) 05/01/1994-12/08/2002?
Opinion Behavior J #134 Mendoza, Vicente V. (VVM) 25/05/1994-05/04/2003?
Opinion Behavior J #135 Francisco, Ricardo J. (RJF) 17/01/1995-13/02/1998
Opinion Behavior J #136 Hermosisima, Jr., Regino C. (RCH) 18/07/1995-18/10/1997
Opinion Behavior J #137 Panganiban, Artemio V. (AVP) 10/10/1995-
Opinion Behavior J #138 Justo P. Torres, Jr. (JPT) 23/03/1996-01/11/1997
Opinion Behavior J #139 Antonio M. Martinez (AMM)17/11/1997-01/02/1999
Opinion Behavior J #140 Quisumbing, Leonardo A. (LAQ) 15/01/1998 -
Opinion Behavior J #141 Fidel P. Purisima (FPP) 27/01/1998-???
Opinion Behavior J #142 Pardo, Bernardo P. (BPP) 06/11/1998-11/2/2002?
Opinion Behavior J #143 Buena, Arturo B. (ABB) 05/01/1999-25/03/2002?
Opinion Behavior J #144 Gonzaga-Reyes, Minerva P. (MPG) 05/01/1999-25/09/2001?
Opinion Behavior J #145 Ynares-Santiago, Ma. Consuelo (MCY)-06/04/1999-
Opinion Behavior J #146 De Leon, Jr., Sabino R. (SRD) ??/10/1999-09/06/2002? or
Opinion Behavior J #147? Sandoval-Gutierrez, Angelina (ASG) 22/12/2000-
Opinion Behavior J #148? Carpio, Antonio T. (ATC) 26/10/2001-
Opinion Behavior J #149? Austria-Martinez, Ma. Alicia (MAA) 12/04/2002-
Opinion Behavior J #150? Corona, Renato C. (RCC) 12/04/2002-
Opinion Behavior J #151? Carpio-Morales, Conchita (CCM) 03/09/2002-
Opinion Behavior J #152? Callejo, Sr., Romeo J. (RJC) 03/09/2002-
Opinion Behavior J #153? Azcuna, Adolfo S. (ASA) 17/10/2002-
Opinion Behavior J #154? Tinga, Dante O. (DOT) 04/07/2003-
Opinion Behavior J #155? Chico-Nazario, Minita (MCN) 14/07/2004-
Opinion Behavior J #156? Garcia, Cancio C. (CCG) 06/10/2004-